Tammy,
Yay for you for trying out CAFE!
Keeping the CAFE menu handy during your individual goal setting conferences is helpful for having students choose strategies that haven't been taught whole group yet. There is also an "if-->then" type of sheet (From Assessment to Conferring: Sample Needs and Strategies) that I used a lot when first starting with CAFE. It is in the CAFE book on page 153 in the appendix.
Then, once your student chooses a strategy to work on, you can teach that strategy one on one OR small group if you end up having a group of students working on the same strategy! I only teach strategies whole group if it is a strategy at least 80% of my students need.
I hope this helps and good luck with all your CAFE endeavors!