Mallory,
Great comments from the "trenches". It is wonderful to hear how you've used research and prof resources to support the Daily 5/CAFE. I love how you say you let students pick their weekly goal and you form groups from there--talk about creating independent, reflective readers!
I hope you stick with your attempts with the CCPensieve. I found that telling my students that I'm taking notes about their successes and strategies we need to work on--and sharing the notes I write with them, helps them (and me) realized what a great teaching/support tool this is--for me and them. I also found that using my iPad (although I did buy a keyboard for it) is less intrusive than my laptop.)