Kathleen~~what you just said is the perfect way to use the Lit Lessons, Book Looks and Focus Lessons!! I agree that many of the books discussed here were not on my "favorites" list, but they did give me ideas on how to build those lessons using my go-to books.
As you also said, we get better at our craft of teaching with practice. I love the words from one of my first graders (after I said for the upteenth time--"I love this book"), "I guess you love books like us--everyone is different and everyone is special." Out of the mouth of babes 